A New Year’s argument got out of hand when a man told his girlfriend to throw bleach in his face…and she did.

Authorities in South Carolina said 56-year-old Barbara Davis was cleaning on New Year’s Day. She and her 54-year-old boyfriend started arguing.

Davis said her boyfriend dared her to throw the bleach at him. She believed he was going to attack her so she followed through.

The man told police that he couldn’t see but refused medical attention. Davis was charged with second-degree domestic violence.